Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!"

Is software development simply more difficult than other kinds of engineering? Are clarifying comments essential to the very nature of well-designed software? Connell responds to readers who have debated these points.

provided by: 
Originally published at Internet.com


Recently, I wrote an article titled Most Software Stinks!. In the many interesting replies I received to the article, two general comments recurred often. One of the comments missed a major point of the article, but the other showed an insight I had overlooked.

The first recurring comment was that software development is simply more difficult than other kinds of engineering and, therefore, cannot be judged by the same standards. In this view, creating software is harder than creating any kind of physical structure, so we cannot expect software to have the same high quality as many bridges and office buildings. (Closely related is the assertion that we cannot expect software to be completed on time and on budget, as physical construction often is.) In my opinion, such an assertion highlights the worst qualities of software developers.

We think we operate on a higher plane of activity than our mechanical and structural engineering brethren. We think the sorry state of software engineering - cancelled projects, lousy quality, missed budgets - is because we do something that is harder than other engineers. The fault, we believe, is not with us, so there is little we can do to improve the performance of software development teams. This is a convenient point of view, if we can sell it. Unfortunately, it is baloney. A great object-oriented design is made better by comments that help the next programmer understand it...

Read article at Internet.com site
Related Articles
- Thoughts on Java and Open Source Security
Java has been historically lucky in the open source field. Sun has been committed to community and industry participation since Java's inception, and by opening up source code Sun has helped foster innovation in areas such as security.
- Tacit Records: .NET Encryption and Java SecurityManager
- eXtreme Programming eXperienced (Part 1)
- Hypewatch: Where Developers Fit In
- Diary of a Developer: To Script or Not to Script
- Updating and Upgrading with Eclipse
- Securing Java Code: Part 1
- JBoss: A Model for Future Software Companies
- Connecting to IBM FileNet 4.0
- Are There Limits to Software Estimation?
Regional Articles
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Alabama
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Alaska
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Arizona
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Arkansas
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" California
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Colorado
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Connecticut
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" DC
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Delaware
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Florida
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Georgia
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Hawaii
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Idaho
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Illinois
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Indiana
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Iowa
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Kansas
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Kentucky
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Louisiana
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Maine
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Maryland
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Massachusetts
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Michigan
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Minnesota
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Mississippi
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Missouri
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Montana
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Nebraska
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Nevada
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" New Hampshire
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" New Jersey
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" New Mexico
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" New York
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" North Carolina
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" North Dakota
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Ohio
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Oklahoma
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Oregon
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Pennsylvania
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Rhode Island
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" South Carolina
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" South Dakota
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Tennessee
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Texas
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Utah
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Vermont
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Virginia
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Washington
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" West Virginia
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Wisconsin
- Follow Up to "Most Software Stinks!" Wyoming

Rss   Delicious   Digg   Add To My Yahoo   Add To My Google   Bookmark   Search Plugin

Topics:
Architecture & Design Languages & Tools Project Management Web Services
Database Microsoft & .NET Security Wireless
Java Open Source Techniques XML